Virtual Football League
Football is always in action. Now you can bet on Virtual Football League
Virtual Horse Classics
Bet on a virtual horse classics. Choose your favorite and win!

Where does England’s U23 XI rank against France, Germany, Italy and Spain? Clue: not that high Featured

Written by 
Published in Football
Thursday, 23 March 2017 08:21

We asked our European offices to compile their strongest under-23 XIs – and the results are rather upsetting for England.

It’s the international week, so what better time to feel miserable (or uplifted, depending on your allegiance) about England’s prospects beyond the 2018 World Cup?

Our European experts in France, Germany, Italy and Spain have compiled their strongest national teams, with one caveat: all players must be aged 23 or under. The results are below...


At risk of upsetting every single Manchester United fan, there is no place for Marcus Rashford. Our logic: he’s a striker, there’s only one spot available and Harry Kane is far superior. The trio behind Kane – Raheem Sterling, Dele Alli and Ross Barkley – are far more suited to attacking midfield and can float around more intelligently.

It’s a rather ominous tale in defence, with Calum Chambers (outclassed against San Marino in 2014), Joe Gomez (only just returned from a year-long injury), John Stones (responsible for most of Manchester City’s errors) and Luke Shaw (out of favour at United). Roll on Euro 2020...
England U23 team: Jordan Pickford (Sunderland); Calum Chambers (Middlesbrough), Joe Gomez (Liverpool), John Stones (Man City), Luke Shaw (Man Utd); Eric Dier (Tottenham), Alex Oxlade-Chamberlain (Arsenal); Raheem Sterling (Man City), Dele Alli (Tottenham), Ross Barkley (Everton); Harry Kane (Tottenham).

Rating: 6/10.


Prepare to be depressed, England fans.

This French U23 team could feasibly challenge for the 2018 World Cup on their own. Monaco newcomers Kylian Mbappe, Thomas Lemar and Benjamin Mendy may only have one cap between them, but their exploits in Ligue 1 and the Champions League puts their combined price tag comfortably beyond €100 million. Throw in a Clasico defensive partnership of Raphael Varane and Samuel Umtiti and it’s quite clear that France are set to take down global football. The days of Olivier Giroud are over.
Rating: 10/10.

Oh, and just to rub it in, the French decided to submit a ‘reserve’ team containing Monaco lynchpin Tiemoue Bakayoko, football’s most decorated youngster Kingsley Coman, and Celtic striking sensation Moussa Dembele. Leave us alone.


England can look at the German attack and think ‘yep, we’ve got you matched’. The Sterling-Alli-Barkley axis may be slightly inferior to Draxler-Goretzka-Sane, but Kane is a superior striker to Timo Werner.

That’s where the joy ends, though.

Joshua Kimmich will soon welcome Niklas Sule to Bayern Munich, with the 21-year-old poised to switch to the German giants in 2017, while Jonathan Tah and Benjamin Henrichs have established themselves in the Bayer Leverkusen defence. Still, it’s hard to not view this outfit with surprise – it is not as strong as previous incarnations.


He may only have two caps, but Gianluigi Donnarumma is already predicted to rival Gianluigi Buffon’s haul of 167 (and counting). The 18-year-old – yep, really – has established himself as AC Milan’s number one and should have fine protection with club team-mate Alessio Romagnoli and Juventus’ Daniele Rugani, both fine talents, in front of him.

Less is known about their attack, with their current squad containing players aged 24 and over, but all the good Italian outfits have been built on defence and the latest crop shows no sign of breaking that tradition.


Spain are building their young army on their own shores… with one exception: Hector Bellerin. However, the Arsenal man may not be in the Premier League for long, as Wednesday’s Euro Papers explains (below).

Read 69 times

Related items

  • England win Euro U19 title as Mason Mount masterminds win over Portugal

    England won their first ever European Under-19 Championship courtesy of a 2-1 win over Portugal in Gori, Georgia.

  • Joachim Low: New-look Germany the best team in the world

    Joachim Low claimed Germany were "still the best team in the world" after they won the Confederations Cup by beating Chile 1-0 in the final.

    Lars Stindl pounced on a defensive error to score the only goal of the game midway through the first half at the Zenit Arena in St Petersburg, although Chile outplayed Low's side for long periods.
    The South American champions created and missed a string of chances and although Stindl's goal came against the run of play, Germany head coach Low insisted victory was deserved.
    "Before the match, (Chile midfielder Arturo) Vidal had said that winning this cup would mean they are the best team in the world. Well, this cup means that at the moment Germany is still the best team in the world. And with such a young side!"
    Low controversially included just three World Cup winners in his squad for the Confederations Cup, but his experimental line-ups excelled throughout the tournament to add another major trophy to their cabinet.
    "Jokingly, we could say that now we have to think about which of the players we left at home we can still add to this team next year," Low said.

    "Seriously though, we have created alternatives, by giving young players experience in such games as has happened here.
    "Winning here and at the European Under-21 Championship does not guarantee the World Cup next year. Germany always belong to the favourites and we will be capable of handling that."
    Borussia Monchengladbach striker Stindl tapped home into an empty net midway through the first half after Chile defender Marcelo Diaz had given the ball away to Timo Werner.
    Chile's Alexis Sanchez, Vidal, Eduardo Vargas and substitute Angelo Sagal all went close, while Germany goalkeeper Marc-Andre ter Stegen saved brilliantly in stoppage time to keep out Arsenal striker Sanchez's free-kick.
    "We played an amazing match and made a huge effort," said Chile head coach Juan Antonio Pizzi.

    "We imposed our game plan for a while, created chances but football is the way it is.

    "Sometimes there are mistakes in football. It is normal to be disappointed when you lose a final. But knowing we can compete against the best teams in the world makes us happy. We will try to keep our style of play."
    Pizzi stood by Diaz, whose first-half blunder led to Stindl's winner and secured Germany their first win in the tournament.
    "Marcelo is sad, as are the rest of the team," Pizzi added.

    "But that's the way he plays and we value the way he plays. We fully support him.

    "We were not as strong as we were in the Copa America Centenario, where we created even more chances, but there we scored. Today, we were not able to do so."

  • Harry Kane rescues England in extraordinary finale against Scotland

    World Cup Qualification Group F, Hampden Park – Scotland 2 (Griffiths 87 90) England 2 (Oxlade-Chamberlain 70, Kane 90+3)

    Harry Kane struck in stoppage time to rescue a 2-2 draw for England after late drama in their World Cup qualifier in Scotland.

    The Spurs man was named captain for the day and responded with a crucial leveller after Leigh Griffiths' quick-fire free-kick double had turned the game on its head three minutes from time.

    Substitute Alex Oxlade-Chamberlain had looked to have put the visitors on course for victory with a 70th minute solo strike, but the sensational finale means Gareth Southgate's men will be delighted to have come away with a point.

    The result sees the Three Lions remain top of Group F after six games played, but their lead was sliced to two points following Slovakia's triumph in Lithuania later on Saturday.

    Scotland are currently fourth on eight points, and will feel their hopes of pushing for the runner-up spot and a potential play-off berth were cruelly dented by Kane's late intervention.

    Harry Kane is still trying to replicate his Spurs form for England - but that goal and the captaincy could be the key. The Spurs hitman has won the past two Premier League Golden Boot awards and finished the season on fire - but he has yet to truly ignite with his country. The 23-year-old has now netted six times in 18 appearances for the Three Lions, but it looked like being another one of those days when he wasted two first-half chances he would have gobbled up in his sleep in his Lilywhites shirt.

    History has shown some players just can't recreate their exploits for their club on the international stage, but Kane is unlikely to fall into that bracket and his late strike to save the day may be a significant sign post and see him appointed captain on a permanent basis.

    Leigh Griffiths (Scotland): The Celtic man was starved of service throughout but worked tirelessly and looked to have won it with two sensational free kicks late on - his first goals in 13 caps for Scotland.


    Scotland: Gordon 6, Tierney 7, Berra 6, Mulgrew 7, Robertson 7, Brown 6, Morrison 5, Snodgrass 6, Armstrong 6, Anya 6, Griffiths 8. Subs: McArthur 6, Fraser 6, Martin n/a.

    England: Hart 5, Walker 6, Cahill 6, Smalling 6, Bertrand 6, Dier 6, Livermore 7, Rashford 5, Alli 6, Lallana 6, Kane 7. Subs: Oxlade-Chamberlain 7, Sterling n/a, Defoe n/a.

    18' - ENGLAND CHANCE! Dier picks out Kane with a chipped ball into the box, but the England skipper can only rifle over the top after taking it down well and cutting back onto his left foot.

    22' - ENGLAND CHANCE! Lallana wriggles free close to the left byline and somehow digs out a lovely cutback for Kane who completely miscues from six yards out.

    51' - ENGLAND HIT THE POST! Livermore cross from the right takes a wicked deflection off a defender and comes back off the near post.

    70' - GOAL! Scotland 0-1 England. Oxlade Chamberlain makes an instant impact! The Arsenal man jinks in from the right and squeezes a shot through a swarm of bodies and into the net via big hands from Gordon.
    87' - GOAL! Scotland 1-1 England. Griffiths steps up and curls a stunning 25-yard free kick beyond Hart and into the far corner of the net.
    90' - GOAL! Scotland 2-1 England. Incredible scenes as curves another sublime free kick over the wall and into the opposite corner. Lightning strikes twice!
    90+3' - GOAL! Scotland 2-2 England. Kane levels for the Three Lions! Sterling rakes a ball from the left to the far post where Kane arrives to volley home.

    Alex Oxlade-Chamberlain scored his first England goal since October 2015 vs Lithuania - 607 days ago

    England are unbeaten in their last five visits to Scotland.

    Scotland are unbeaten in their last six home games.

    Griffiths scored his first international goals on his 13th cap. They were also the first goals England have conceded in this World Cup qualifying campaign

    Kane scored his first goal for England since May 2016, after a run of 575 minutes without one.

  • Germany 7 San Marino 0: Wagner hits hat-trick for world champions

    Germany put San Marino to the sword in Nuremberg to keep their World Cup qualifying campaign on track ahead of the Confederations Cup.

  • Wagner scores hat-trick in Germany stroll

    Forward Sandro Wagner scored a hat-trick, his first goals for Germany, to lead the world champions to a predictably comfortable 7-0 stroll against minnows San Marino.

    Amin Younes and Julian Brandt also scored their first international goals while Julian Draxler and Shkodran Mustafi shared the others as Germany maintained their 100 percent record after six games in European Group C.

    The visitors, already beaten 8-0 at home by the Germans earlier in the group, remained without a point.
    Northern Ireland stayed five points behind Germany in second place after an stoppage time goal by Stuart Dallas gave them a 1-0 win in Azerbaijan.

    Czech Republic, on nine points, are a further four behind in third after drawing 1-1 in Norway. Azerbaijan have seven points and Norway four.

    Germany fielded players from 11 different clubs in their starting line-up, the first time that has happened in 57 years, as coach Joachim Loew gave starts to some of his less experienced players.

    The game failed to attract a full house in Nuremberg and was embarrassingly one-sided with Germany enjoying 77 percent of possession and managing 18 efforts on goal while their opponents failed to muster a single shot.

    Germany took 11 minutes to break the deadlock when Draxler fired home after a group of San Marino defenders got in each other's way and failed to clear the ball.
    Wagner, winning his second cap after being called up last month for the first time at the age of 29, got in front of his marker to head in Joshua Kimmich's cross for the second five minutes later.

    Wagner struck again in the 29th minute before Younes got in on the act before halftime after more poor defending from the visitors.

    Goalkeeper Elia Benedettini tried to punch away Kimmich's corner, the ball bounced off defender Pier Filippo Mazza and Younes slotted home.

    Mustafi added the fifth two minutes after the re-start, scrambling the ball home despite a poor first touch after San Marino again failed to clear a corner.

    Substitute Brandt scored the best goal of the night when he headed in a delightful dinked ball from Kimmich and Wagner completed his hat-trick in the 84th minute with an easy header from another Kimmich assist.

Leave a comment


Conte ditches the tracksuit and praises his Champions

Conte ditches the tracksuit and praises his Champions

Chelsea manager Antonio Conte ditched the tracksuit and looked on as his side secured a dramatic thr...

African Football

Football Transfers

Virtual Football League
Football is always in action. Now you can bet on Virtual Football League

Sponsored Links

Virtual Football League
Football is always in action. Now you can bet on Virtual Football League

Like Us On Facebook

Formula 1


    Connect With Us

    Contact Us

    Email: This email address is being protected from spambots. You need JavaScript enabled to view it.

    Our Sponsors